My dog started out on these fine. She ate them with a meal, covered in some all natural peanut butter. If she licked the peanut butter off, she even carried it to her crate to continue to try to eat it like a treat. But after the first two dosages, she started having diarrhea in her crate over night. Her worst day, I had to wash out her bedding and crate (again), then she vomited bile, so I did not feed her breakfast to give her belly some time to settle. This day, I help back on her fish oil. No accidents that night. The next day, back on to one capsule, and diarrhea in her crate again. I may look for other options, but I know this one is not it. And unfortunately, I set this up as a subscribe and save, and I have a second bottle being delivered today by accident.