I read the mixed reviews and wasn't sure if my picky eaters would take these, and amazingly BOTH DID!!! One of my cats is near the very end of her life. She's stopped taking most food and is barely drinking because of her urinary problems. The prognosis doesn't look good, and the care is extremely expensive. I took a look shot with this, just hoping to ease maybe some of her discomfort. I had it shipped overnight and was just hoping that at least one of my cats with urinary problems would take them. They wanted more after giving them the recommended amount (I didn't oblige, they weren't that happy about that part). She ate the whole thing after I broke it into crumbles!! I really don't know that this will be enough for her, but I had to try something, anything! So far, extremely pleased. I will update if anything changes (but it probably won't be the fault of the product). Update: both of them LOVE these treats still and I think it's bringing my baby back to us! I can't say that it's the treats alone, I'm sure they are correcting something though that was causing her major issues. She's eating and drinking quite a bit better after a few days of these!